On the afternoon of June 16, the People's Court of District 1, Ho Chi Minh City sentenced Nguyen Xuan Huong Trang (Trang Nemo, born in 1992), Pham Quyen Quy, Nguyen Ngoc Khuong (both 23 years old), and Phan Hoang Nam (24 years old) for disturbing public order.
According to the panel of judges, the defendants' actions caused social disorder. Defendant Nam has a criminal record that has not been cleared, so he needs to be severely punished.
For defendants Trang, Quy, and Khuong, who committed the crime for the first time and showed remorse, the panel of judges considered partially reducing their sentences.
The People's Court sentenced defendants Nguyen Xuan Huong Trang, Pham Quyen Quy, and Nguyen Ngoc Khuong to 9 months in prison; and defendant Phan Hoai Nam to 1 year in prison for disturbing public order.
Defendant Trang Nemo at the trial. (Photo: Hoang Tho)
Previously, at the trial, the People's Procuracy proposed that the People's Court sentence the defendants Trang, Quy, and Khuong to 6-12 months in prison; and the defendant Nam to 12-18 months in prison.
The People's Procuracy assessed that the defendants' actions had disrupted social order and security, and that a severe sentence was needed to serve as a deterrent. However, the defendants Trang, Quy, and Khuong confessed honestly, had no previous criminal records, and were first-time offenders, so their sentences should be reduced.
Regarding Ms. Pham Le Khanh's request to prosecute the defendants for the additional crime of intentionally causing injury, the People's Procuracy said there was no basis and requested the panel of judges not to accept it.
According to the indictment, Huong Trang is the owner of Trang Nemo store on Nguyen Trai Street, Nguyen Cu Trinh Ward, District 1. Due to a conflict in online sales business, Trang and Tran Nguyen Tra My made an appointment to resolve the matter at the store.
At around 2:45 p.m. on January 16, My, Pham Le Khanh, and Tran Thi Hoang Yen went to Trang Nemo store. Afterwards, My and Yen went into the store to apologize, while Khanh stood outside.
At around 3:00 p.m. the same day, while My was apologizing to Trang, Khanh entered the store and called My back, causing a conflict between Khanh and Trang.
When Trang used her hand to pull Khanh's mask, this person cursed at Trang. Hearing that, Trang's employee Quy and Trang rushed in, grabbed Khanh's hair, hit him in the head and back, and kicked him in the stomach. At this time, Yen tried to stop her but was also beaten by Khuong.
Seeing the fight, Trang Nemo store security guards Nam and Tuan ran in. Then, Nam and Tuan jumped in to beat Khanh.
According to the forensic examination, Khanh suffered multiple soft tissue injuries, scattered swelling and bruising in various parts of his body, with a body damage rate of 3%, while Yen had no recorded injuries.
At the police station, Trang, Quy, Khuong, Tuan and Nam admitted their actions.
On April 20, the Investigation Police Agency of District 1 Police issued a decision to prosecute the case and prosecute Trang, Quy, Khuong, Tuan and Nam for disturbing public order.
Hoang Tho
Useful
Emotion
Creative
Unique
Source
Comment (0)