MU must rectify their mistake with James Garner.

Manchester United are reportedly considering the possibility of bringing James Garner back to Old Trafford.

James Garner's consistent, mature, and high-quality performances under manager David Moyes have been a major surprise in the Premier League this season, and have also sent a clear signal to England manager Thomas Tuchel ahead of the 2026 World Cup squad selection.

With their midfield still in turmoil, Manchester United have reason to look back at a familiar name. Garner is a product of the MU academy, joining the club in 2009 at the age of 8 and making his first-team debut in 2018.

However, the midfielder only made a mere 7 appearances for the "Red Devils" before being loaned out to Watford, Nottingham Forest, and then sold to Everton in 2022.

The decision to leave Old Trafford was once seen as a step backward, but in reality, it opened the way for Garner's sustainable development. Since arriving at Goodison Park, the midfielder born in 2001 quickly became a key player, reaching over 100 appearances and playing a crucial role in Everton's style of play. The Merseyside club is actively negotiating a contract extension, showing they are unwilling to easily lose such a strategic asset.

However, renewed interest from Manchester United could force Garner to reconsider his future. His contract with Everton expires next summer, opening up the possibility of negotiations for a reasonable fee, a factor that suits Manchester United's financial situation and personnel needs.

Professionally, Garner possesses all the qualities of a modern box-to-box midfielder.

Professionally, Garner possesses all the qualities of a modern box-to-box midfielder: excellent tempo control, accurate passing, intelligent pressing, and effective game reading ability. His understanding of the Premier League environment makes him a low-risk option in the transfer market.

Garner's performances against big rivals like Man City, Arsenal, and Liverpool this season show that he is in no way inferior to the league's top midfielders.

From a talent who was sold cheaply, Garner has proven his worth through perseverance and maturity. The next six months promise to be a pivotal period, as he stands before two major doors: the chance to be called up by Tuchel for the 2026 World Cup and the possibility of returning to Old Trafford in a completely different role.