Mr. Sun and Ms. Wang (in Miyun District, Beijing, China) did not get along well and often argued. One day, after getting drunk, Sun felt extremely resentful and dissatisfied with his wife. In revenge, this man went crazy and ran to the cemetery and destroyed his wife's parents' grave.
After digging about 20cm, Ton gradually calmed down, felt that what he was doing was not right, so he finally stopped and quickly restored the grave. It was not until recently that Ms. Vuong learned about her husband's behavior. Too angry, she immediately asked for a divorce.
Even though they had broken up, Ms. Vuong was still angry. She believed that her ex-husband had intentionally dug up the grave, destroying the feng shui of her parents' resting place, forcing her to move her parents' grave to another place. This woman asked Ton to compensate her, but he refused.
Ms. Vuong sued Mr. Ton in court, demanding compensation for all repair costs, grave relocation, and mental damage compensation, totaling 30,000 yuan (about 105 million VND).
Husband and wife argued, then learned that his wife was having an affair, the man was so angry that he lost his mind. (Illustration: Freepik)
In court, when asked why he acted like that, Ton said he lost his composure because of alcohol, and that discovering his wife was having an affair made him lose his temper and act impulsively. This man said that he was actually a victim and that his ex-wife's lawsuit against him was unreasonable.
However, the court held that the grave is the resting place of the deceased, a special place for future generations to remember and pay respect to their deceased relatives. Ms. Vuong suffered a certain amount of mental pain when her parents' grave was excavated, and the violator must be responsible for the material and mental damage.
During the marriage, the two did not resolve the conflict properly; Sun resolved it by acting against public morals, causing certain mental damage to Wang. The court held that Wang's claim for compensation for mental damage was legally valid, but the amount she requested was too high.
Ms. Vuong's request for the cost of repairing the grave and replacing the objects in the grave was also not supported by the court because there was no evidence to prove a legal causal relationship between the cost and Ms. Vuong's act of moving her parents' grave and Mr. Ton's actions.
Finally, the Miyun District Court ruled that Mr. Sun must compensate Ms. Wang 8,000 yuan (about 28 million VND) for mental damage within 7 days from the date the judgment came into effect; it rejected Ms. Wang's other requests.
Source
Comment (0)