From an advanced country "falling rapidly" to middle class, what is happening to the Italian economy?

The article by author Federico Fubini, published on the Corriere della Sera website (Italy), mentions the stagnant state of the Italian economy over the past 30 years, and assesses the prospects for the coming time.

During his 190-minute press conference in early 2024, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni did not mention a single number. As the leader of an economy worth 2,000 billion euros ($2,186 billion) and exporting 600 billion euros, Prime Minister Meloni's silence is a question mark that needs an explanation.

Từ quốc gia tiên tiến 'tụt dốc không phanh' xuống hạng trung bình, điều gì đang xảy ra với nền kinh tế Italy?

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni at a press conference in early 2024, January 4 in Rome. (Source: AP)

Faded

First of all, let’s start with the figures that Prime Minister Meloni failed to cite. In fact, she did not mention the clear slide of the Italian economy, from being an advanced country to a middle-income country and increasingly invisible on the global economic map. This is happening despite the thousands of dynamic businesses and millions of talented professionals operating in Italy.

Ms. Meloni cannot say that the share of the Italian economy in the current European Union (EU) has decreased by 26% in the period 1995-2023 (from 17.2% to 12.7%). In the same period, the share of the Italian economy in the Eurozone economy has also decreased from about 20% 30 years ago to 15% today.

Some economists might argue that this decline in share is due to the growth of the new economies in Central and Eastern Europe. But that argument is not convincing when comparing Italy with France: the French share of the Eurozone has hardly changed since 1995, while the Italian share has declined and actually lost its position significantly (according to the European Commission database).

Furthermore, Prime Minister Meloni cannot say that the comparison within Europe is too harsh for Italy. For example, if the entire EU, consisting of 27 member states, is compared with the United States, the bloc is also losing ground. In dollar terms, in 1996, the EU and the United States had a GDP of about $8 trillion.

However, despite strong growth in emerging countries in Central and Eastern Europe, the US economy in 2022 was 52% larger than the EU's, a gap of nearly $10 trillion that may have widened further in 2023.

When globalization began in 1980, GDP per capita in the US was equivalent to the average of the 27 EU countries (although incomes in the Eastern Bloc member states were still low).

By 2022, the average income per capita in the US will reach 76,300 USD, while the average income in the EU will only reach 37,400 USD, less than half of the US, despite the very strong recovery of member states in Eastern Europe such as Estonia and Slovenia. This difference has increased especially since the global economic crisis in 2008, the first major disruption in 30 years of globalization (according to data from the World Bank - WB).

In essence, Italy is losing its position in an economic region that is itself rapidly shrinking relative to the world’s production and technology levels. Italy is falling behind a group of countries that are already slowing down. The result is a significant reduction in the region’s growth rate compared to the global trend.

In 1992, per capita income in the United States was only 9% higher than in Italy in current dollar terms. By 2022, it was more than double that in Italy ($76,000 versus $34,000). It may be wrong to state that difference in current dollar terms, which should take into account exchange rate fluctuations and purchasing power, but if this depreciation is taken into account, it still makes little difference.

And the future is vague

Also in the press conference in early 2024, Ms. Meloni had other numbers that she certainly did not want to talk about. For example, the numbers show how closed the Italian economy is to the world. Compared to the current size of the economy, from 2005 to 2022, Italy would have received a total of 120 billion USD in foreign direct investment (FDI) if it were considered a similar economic proportion to France; at the same time, there would have been an additional 600 billion Euros if Italy had foreign investment equal to the EU average since 2005 (always considered as a proportion of total output).

As for FDI, Italy has only achieved a cumulative value of 27% of GDP since 2005, much lower than France's 40%, Germany's 48%, and Spain's nearly 60%.

Italy’s production links with the rest of the world are less developed than those of advanced economies. It imports less capital, knowledge, skills, and technological processes and innovates less. It is less present in complex production chains and organizations outside its borders.

All this has limited Italy’s capabilities. Despite numerous individual cases to the contrary, as a country, Italy is clearly shrinking (according to data from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development - OECD).

Italy is losing ground in an economic region that is itself rapidly losing ground relative to the world's manufacturing and technological capabilities. (Source: Reuters)

On the other hand, analysis by the Confindustria Research Center also shows that the trend in FDI in 2023, which recorded a more positive effect in the US, has slowed down in Italy and Europe compared to 2022.

It would be too much to expect Prime Minister Meloni to address these issues in her recent press conference. A government leader’s press conference is not a news bulletin or a seminar. However, one might expect a clearer stance on this important issue of the country from a young, articulate female prime minister who is interested in what is happening in the world and runs a government that is likely to last a long time.

(according to Corriere della Sera)

Source