What do experts say about the accusation that Jungkook (BTS) plagiarized music?

Recently, the media outlet Dispatch announced its findings after investigating the plagiarism allegations against BTS member Jungkook for his solo single "Seven". This is the initial result given by producer Yang Joon Young. This is also the producer of Fin.KL's song "Time of Mask", which is said to be the original work that Jungkook "plagiarized".

What do experts say about the accusation that Jungkook (BTS) plagiarized music?

Earlier this week, Yang Joon Young's plagiarism allegations were made public through various media outlets, attracting widespread public attention. Yang Joon Young asserted that although the two songs use different keys, they still use the same note/scale sequence in the 4-bar section.

Dispatch announced that it found no similarities between the two songs. Photo: IT.

According to Yang Joon Young, the "problematic" part of "Seven", is between 00:55 and 01:03, with lyrics beginning with "You love when I jump right in. All of me I'm offering...". In "Time of Mask", the alleged similar part is between 00:52 and 01:10.

To verify Yang Joon Young's accusation, Dispatch tested to find similarities. However, Dispatch found that because "Seven" and "Time of Mask" use different scales, it was difficult to convert the two songs into a completely matching form. However, Dispatch still proceeded to convert the two songs.

Ultimately, Dispatch concluded that no element completely overlaps between the two songs, whether it involves key, chord progression, tempo, or note arrangement.

“To consider plagiarism, at least two similar components must be found, such as the same melody and chord progression. In this case, no such components were found,” an expert told Dispatch .

Previously, BTS' management company BIGHIT MUSIC stated, "We affirm that the allegations of copyright infringement related to Jungkook's 'Seven' are not true." They added, "'Seven' is a song made through the collaboration of five foreign composers and the song is a new creation, completely unrelated to the song in the domestic album from 23 years ago as some people have claimed. These are one-sided statements that do not meet any criteria such as similarity and other principles in determining plagiarism."

Source: https://danviet.vn/chuyen-gia-noi-gi-ve-cao-buoc-jungkook-bts-dao-nhac-20230824122330933.htm